You have to pick:

heaven

in it's purest form

Unless they are hot.

Also, what about what doesn't get eaten. That is NOT going to smell good in three days.

Would the never ask me for five bucks again if I have it to them?

Yep, they will never ask you again if you give it to them, otherwise they constantly ask you for as long as you live.

The smell you'd get use to, rotten cheese and meats, you'd get use to it until it didn't smell.

Also since it rained only pizza toppings either our blood is marinara sauce or we'd die from dehydration/diabetes/heart attack real fast.